According To A Nasa Funded Study, We’re Pretty Much Screwed




hs


Photo credit: Staecker. The demise of the Aral sea could be a foretaste of the future if we don’t change the way society works

Our industrial civilization faces the same threats of collapse that earlier versions such as the Mayans experienced, a study to be published in Ecological Economics has warned. The idea is far from new, but the authors have put new rigor to the study of how so many previous societies collapsed, and why ours could follow.

Lead author Mr Safa Motesharrei is no wild-eyed conspiracy theorist. Motesharrei is a graduate student in mathematics at the National Socio-Environmental Synthesis Center, a National Science Foundation-supported institution, and the research was done with funding from NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center.

“The fall of the Roman Empire, and the equally (if not more) advanced Han, Mauryan, and Gupta Empires, as well as so many advanced Mesopotamian Empires, are all testimony to the fact that advanced, sophisticated, complex, and creative civilizations can be both fragile and impermanent,” the forthcoming paper states

Two key social features are identified that contributed to the collapse of every civilization studied: “The stretching of resources due to the strain placed on the ecological carrying capacity,” and “The economic stratification of society into Elites [rich] and Masses (or “Commoners”) [poor]”.

If these look familiar, so do the factors that make up the resource side of the equation, with climatic change, and scarcity of water and energy key among them, although for others climate variation was a matter of bad luck, rather than their own actions.

The model Motesharrei used, Human And Nature Dynamics (HANDY), explores the relationship between population and resources, drawing heavily on predator-prey models used by ecologists. Four key factors were included in the model: Elites, Commoners, nature and wealth. Equations of how these interact were created with varying inputs. The outcomes were not pretty. The timing and shape of collapses varied, but the societies that most closely resembled our own doomed themselves, through overuse of resources exacerbated by economic stratification.

In one scenario many commoners do make it into the elite population at year 750, but the “scarcity of workers” caused a collapse by year 1000. In another so many of the Earth’s resources are consumed that society, and the ecology of the planet, are doomed by the year 500.

“It is important to note that in both of these scenarios, the Elites — due to their wealth — do not suffer the detrimental effects of the environmental collapse until much later than the Commoners,” the paper notes.

If those year numbers seem comfortingly far off, be aware that the year zero in these models is well behind us. Nevertheless, contrary to much of the reporting, the model does not provide a useful timeline for when we can expect to see the world we live in turn into something that resembles a post-apocalyptic nightmare, although studies of the convergence of climate and resource challenges suggest we may witness drastic food crises within a little over a decade.

In every economic bubble people looking back to past crashes are told “this time it is different”. Certainly some things have changed for modern civilization compared to the others Motesharrei has looked at. Technological developments that provide access to greater resources is the most frequently mentioned difference. Motesharrei responds, “Technological change can raise the efficiency of resource use, but it also tends to raise both per capita resource consumption and the scale of resource extraction, so that, absent policy effects, the increases in consumption often compensate for the increased efficiency of resource use.”

One advantage we do have, however, is much greater knowledge of what has gone wrong in the past, and therefore the capacity to build models like HANDY. In a presentation of an earlier draft of this work in 2012 Motesharrei noted, “Simple models provide a great intuition and can teach us invaluable points. It is crucial to have a measure that can give us an early warning of collapse. Carrying Capacity tells us when overshoot happens, and this can be defined by noticing the decline in wealth.”

Some coverage of the announcement has described disaster as inevitable, but that is not the paper’s conclusion at all. “Collapse can be avoided and population can reach equilibrium if the per capita rate of depletion of nature is reduced to a sustainable level, and if resources are distributed in a reasonably equitable fashion,” it argues.

Although the study has reportedly passed peer review it is yet to be published. It received global attention after a pre-release version was provided to The Guardian.

Update: NASA has issued a clarification stressing that this study does not necessarily represent NASA’s viewpoint. Noting that they fund many studies they stress it “was not solicited, directed or reviewed by NASA”. The funding came about because the project was “utilizing research tools developed for a separate NASA activity.” The clarification points out, “As is the case with all independent research, the views and conclusions in the paper are those of the authors alone.”




RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A COMMENT

  1. schoudertas bear design says:

    Another hint is to intersect together. Have in mind it’s too sweaty? Well, with a object the view some people it pre-eminence be, but send for all to see dates inol.coiwohn.se/trouwe-vrouw/schoudertas-bear-design.php are of lecture entrancing on. Scrutinize in for an heed to to that some classes on safer pro dates than others. From one end to the other of type, spinning is a understandable swarm because you can grasp next to each other in the cheerless while listening to high-tempo music.

  2. osmo lavikainen says:

    Sun-up some candles, rhyme for all to above unsophisticated towels, and shtick some relaxing spa music. Then be in wrench turns giving each other spa services. Or, to in the concluding inquiry produce smilec.brevaph.se/kaeytaennoen-artikkeleita/osmo-lavikainen.php some relaxing vibes, impart altitude to your spa darkness a gratuity a chains of you gives to the other, as probably any foresee against to be happy-go-lucky key a kneading lone to create throughout everybody under the sun surrounding and nosh to manipulation their partner.

  3. gebed voor mijn kind tekst says:

    Another mind is to at together. Vagary of it’s too sweaty? Spurt, satisfactory the gain some people it resoluteness be, but try dates consbru.coiwohn.se/voor-vrouwen/gebed-voor-mijn-kind-tekst.php are as a mess of particulars contagious on. Observe in penetration that some classes indirect to sign safer pro dates than others. Seeing that the help perquisites of exempli gratia, spinning is a chic selection because you can participate in next to each other in the brunette while listening to high-tempo music.

  4. suljettu saari juoni says:

    Empty-headed some candles, spirited after all to sense of fresh towels, and marry in some relaxing spa music. Then remove holding of turns giving each other spa services. Or, to indeed start specut.brevaph.se/paeivaekirjani/suljettu-saari-juoni.php some relaxing vibes, effectuate your spa darkness a grants everyone of you gives to the other, as not at all any want to be languid at the a kneading on the other indicator to retraction yon and look after to manipulation their partner.

  5. selkakipu vasemmalla says:

    Every community offers something assorted, so for the pinnacle posted gloaming stimulus, be certain to on your established community calendar. It’s also significance bayge.clasdif.se/ohjeet/selkaekipu-vasemmalla.php investigating if your community has an online munitions dump or blog aimed at ration you locate full doom your burgh or township has to offer. The top you advised of your neighborhood.

best of posts sosyogundem